(Cutline: From left to right: District 2 incumbent John Barnes, District 4 incumbent Rachel Farris, District 4 challenger Alroy Headden, District 4 challenger Lloyd Jones and District 6 challenger Wayne Shider.)
We won't have a story in Tuesday's paper but here are some of my notes and
observations from Monday night's debate that was sponsored by the Colleton
County High School Student Government Association.
Overall, it was a pretty interesting yet civil debate. Five of the nine candidates showed up. Read on to find out about some humorous moments, a couple of incorrect statements and
a revelation or two. Also, feel free to add to or dispute any of my observations. That's one of the benefits of having an interactive media (immediate criticism!)
Revelations:
District 6 Trustee Wayne Shider told the crowd that the School Board
discussed a couple of other facility proposals before Superintendent
Charles Gale proposed the controversial $90 million plan that includes
building a new $70 million high school and a new football stadium and a new elementary school in Cottageville.
Shider said those plans included adding a gym at Forest Circle Middle
School and closing Colleton Middle. "I agree whole-heartedly with the
$90 million," he said, adding that the others were just piece-mealing.
(Note: I apologize that I didn't have time after the meeting to go more in-depth about the plans or when those discussions took place. I hope to follow up on that sooner than later.)
Corrections:
Shider also made the first of a couple of incorrect or misleading statements made by
incumbents - at the least, they conflicted with earlier information
distributed to the press. Let us clarify:
Shider said he wasn't certain the $90 million plan even included a tax increase.
Maybe not for the folks at Edisto Beach and some other residents with homes over $100,000 but the vast majority of Colleton County residents will more than likely see an increase. (The median assessed value of Colleton County homes is about $67,000.)
The reason they will see an increase is because the state legislature last year gave owners of occupied homes worth more than $100,000 an exemption. That means many will be paying less than previously, despite the school debt tax increase. People with homes under the $100,000 threshold, however, won't see a savings because they already have the exemption. This has been reported repeatedly during the last couple of months.
(Note: To be fair to Mr. Shider, we just recently had to run a correction for a mistaken headline in a story involving him.)
The other inaccurate statement came from incumbent Rachel Farris who said that the school district does not have enough 8 percent borrowing capacity to build a new elementary school for Cottageville. (School districts are only allowed to borrow 8 percent of their county's assessed value without a referendum.)
Actually, at least before the alternative financing program was approved, the district had just enough to pay for the new elementary school but it would have been maxed out for the next several years.
Other tidbits:
- Shider, who has served on the School Board for 21 years, mentioned he wanted to run "one more time."
- There were a couple of humorous moments when Farris jokingly - I think - kept blaming opponent Alroy Headden for her difficulties with the microphone.
- Farris also rolled her eyes and smiled when Headden, who's running on a platform of good maintenance for schools, seemed to find a way to squeeze the issue into most of his answers.
- Josh Blackwell, Colleton County High social studies teacher, and Prenita Hudson, Student Government president (pictured), did a good job moderating the event.
- Jones is the only non-incumbent to favor the idea of borrowing $90 million without a referendum. He said people need to trust the School Board. "I feel certain the board made the right decision," he said. "If we put everything on the ballot then we don't need a board."
- District 2 candidate Timmy Benton missed the last two debates because of prior engagements, giving Barnes no one to debate. Barnes said he's the best candidate because he's committed to public education and has seen the system work for his own children. "I don't think it's right to jump on the political bandwagon and simply point fingers," he said.
- Like a previous post mentioned, it was a small to moderate crowd with
about 40 people, many of them students.
- I hate to come across as mean - because I don't think I am - but I couldn't have been the only person in the room to cringe when I saw the word "incumbent" repeatedly misspelled "incumbant" on the power point presentation. Hey, it's only an observation.
Recent Comments